Minn. lawmakers defend voter ID measure validity

ST. PAUL, Minn. (AP) — Lawyers for the Minnesota Legislature argue that lawmakers deserve wide latitude to design constitutional ballot questions as they fight an attempt to scuttle a photo ID measure awaiting voters in November, according to new court papers.

In a brief filed Monday with the state Supreme Court, the Legislature’s lawyers said the proposed constitutional amendment to require a valid photo ID for voting was placed on the ballot properly and shouldn’t be removed. The brief urges justices to respect “the very broad and exclusive discretion” of the Legislature to fashion amendments.

On July 17, the high court will hear oral arguments from amendment opponents, who argue that the question is vague and misleading. They say it leaves doubts about how the new requirement would be carried out and how voting rights would be protected if people failed to bring the right ID to the polls.

The ballot language approved in May by the Legislature reads, “Shall the Minnesota Constitution be amended to require all voters to present valid photo identification to vote and to require the state to provide free identification to eligible voters, effective July 1, 2013?”

Legislative attorney Thomas Boyd contends such ballot questions aren’t traditionally treated as the sole explanation of the initiative. He wrote in his brief that more than 40 of the 213 amendments put before voters since statehood had such limited detail that reading the question alone wouldn’t even help decipher the topic.

“The Legislature has never intended or expected that the ballot question would be a substitute for encouraging voters to actually read and analyze the proposed amendments for themselves,” Boyd wrote.

Boyd is from a Minneapolis law firm hired at public expense to represent the Legislature’s interests. Republicans in charge of the House and Senate decided to intervene in the lawsuit over the objections of Democrats. The amendment was placed on the fall ballot on party-line votes.

Minnesota Secretary of State Mark Ritchie, a Democrat, has declined to take a side in the lawsuit despite being the named defendant and chief elections officer.

Plaintiffs in the case, a coalition of groups opposed to the photo ID concept, have until next Monday to file their written brief.

Ritchie has urged the court to decide the case no later than Aug. 27 so ballots can be designed and printed in enough time for voters to access absentee ballots.

SportsPlus

Mower County

A new reason to run: After diagnosis, Austin grad is looking to raise funds to fight MS

Mower County

SWCD board chair to serve as VP for state group

Mower County

Minnesota DNR: Enjoy the ice over the holidays, but check it often

Education

Education Briefs

Crime, Courts & Emergencies

Convictions: Dec. 9-16

Crime, Courts & Emergencies

G. Meadow man sentenced for drug charges, challenges pre-investigation in 2nd case

Mower County

Eastbound I-90 lane, ramps reopen in Austin as Cedar River bridge completed

News

A Place for Romantics: New downtown bookstore for romance is a dream for its owner

Agriculture

Voigts honored for conservation farming practices

Business

Austin realtor honored with Realtor Emeritus Award

Agriculture

Grant available to aid in weather resilience

Mower County

In Your Community: Asian Student Union donate 30 blankets to Mayo Clinic

Mower County

In Your Community: Austin Youth Hockey Peewee B shops for family

Brownsdale

In Your Community: Brownsdale Study Club

Mower County

In Your Community: Duplicate Bridge

Mower County

In Your Community: Mower County Senior Center

News

Minnesota House tie in peril after judge rules DFL lawmaker can’t be sworn in

News

Unwelcome holiday guests: RSV, flu and COVID-19 on the rise

News

Minnesota deputies saw 250 animals suffering at purported rescue. Weeks later, only 70 were left

News

Federal Reserve cuts its key rate by a quarter-point but envisions fewer reductions next year

Education

Riverland Community College celebrates remarkable enrollment growth

Mower County

Photos: Singing the song of the season

Mower County

Driver in crash that injured Wyatt Hamlin arrested in Tennessee

Mower County

UPDATE: Thursday brings another chance for snow, winter weather advisory issued